Self-hosting vs SaaS: Our Infrastructure Decisions for a Bootstrapped Startup

When you're bootstrapping a startup, every dollar counts. The choice between self-hosting and SaaS solutions can mean the difference between profitability and burning through runway. After six months of building Webceive's infrastructure, here's our transparent breakdown of costs, trade-offs, and lessons learned.

The Decision Framework

Before diving into specific tools, we established criteria for every infrastructure decision:

Cost sensitivity: Monthly costs under $100 total Technical control: Ability to customize and integrate deeply Data ownership: Complete control over customer and business data Scalability: Can grow from 0 to 1000 customers without major rewrites Risk management: No single point of vendor failure Time investment: Reasonable setup time vs. ongoing savings

The SaaS Temptation

The enterprise SaaS sales pitches were compelling:

HubSpot: "All-in-one CRM and marketing automation"

• Cost: $2,000/month for Professional tier
• Promise: "Set it and forget it" marketing automation

Salesforce: "World's #1 CRM"

• Cost: $300/user/month for Enterprise
• Promise: "Unlimited customization" (with developer team)

Mailchimp: "Easy email marketing"

• Cost: $300/month for 10,000 subscribers
• Promise: "Beautiful templates and automation"

Vercel: "Zero-config deployment"

• Cost: $400/month for team features
• Promise: "Deploy with git push"

Total SaaS Cost: $3,000+/month ($36,000+/year)

The Self-Hosting Alternative

Here's what we built instead and the real costs:

CRM: Twenty vs. HubSpot

Twenty CRM (Self-hosted)

• Setup time: 8 hours
• Monthly cost: $0 (included in VPS)
• Features: Full CRM, custom fields, API access, unlimited users
• Customization: Complete control over data model and workflows

vs. HubSpot Professional

• Setup time: 2 hours
• Monthly cost: $2,000
• Features: CRM + marketing automation (limited customization)
• Customization: Pay $5,000+ for custom properties and workflows

winner: Twenty CRM savings: $24,000/year Trade-off: Initial learning curve, no phone support

Email Marketing: Listmonk vs. Mailchimp

Listmonk (Self-hosted)

• Setup time: 4 hours
• Monthly cost: $0 (included in VPS)
• Features: Unlimited subscribers, A/B testing, analytics, custom templates
• Limitations: No drag-and-drop builder (HTML/CSS required)

vs. Mailchimp Standard

• Setup time: 1 hour
• Monthly cost: $300 (for 10,000 subscribers)
• Features: Templates, automation, basic analytics
• Limitations: Limited customization, subscriber limits

winner: Listmonk savings: $3,600/year Trade-off: Need HTML/CSS skills for templates

Website Hosting: Docker + nginx vs. Vercel

Self-hosted with Docker

• Setup time: 12 hours (including SSL, domains, CI/CD)
• Monthly cost: $20 (VPS portion)
• Features: Multiple sites, unlimited bandwidth, full control
• Performance: Sub-second load times globally

vs. Vercel Pro

• Setup time: 30 minutes
• Monthly cost: $400 (team features + bandwidth)
• Features: Git integration, edge functions, analytics
• Limitations: Vendor lock-in, bandwidth costs

winner: Self-hosted savings: $4,560/year Trade-off: DevOps knowledge required

Infrastructure: VPS vs. AWS/GCP

Single VPS (Linode/DigitalOcean)

• Setup time: 16 hours (Docker Compose, WireGuard, monitoring)
• Monthly cost: $80
• Specs: 8GB RAM, 4 vCPUs, 160GB SSD, unlimited transfer
• Capacity: Handles 10,000+ users easily

vs. AWS equivalent

• Setup time: 20+ hours (learning curve, complexity)
• Monthly cost: $300+ (EC2, RDS, CloudFront, etc.)
• Features: Auto-scaling, managed services, enterprise support
• Complexity: Multiple services, complicated billing

winner: Single VPS savings: $2,640/year Trade-off: Manual scaling, single point of failure

Our Final Self-Hosted Stack

Production infrastructure

• VPS: Linode 8GB ($80/month)
• Operating System: Ubuntu 22.04 LTS
• Containerization: Docker + Docker Compose
• Web Server: nginx with Let's Encrypt SSL
• VPN: WireGuard for secure access
• Monitoring: Prometheus + Grafana
• Backups: Automated daily backups to S3

Applications

• Website: Next.js + Tailwind CSS (static export)
• CRM: Twenty CRM (self-hosted)
• Email Marketing: Listmonk
• Secret Management: HashiCorp Vault
• Task Management: AppFlowy (self-hosted)
• Analytics: Plausible Analytics (self-hosted)

Development tools

• Version Control: GitHub (free tier)
• CI/CD: GitHub Actions (free tier)
• Testing: Jest + Cypress (open source)
• Documentation: Markdown files in repo

Total Monthly Cost: $87 Annual Cost: $1,044 SaaS Equivalent: $36,000+ Savings: $34,956/year (97% reduction)

The Hidden Costs Analysis

Time investment breakdown

Initial setup (one-time)

• Infrastructure setup: 40 hours
• Application configuration: 24 hours
• Security hardening: 16 hours
• Documentation: 12 hours
• Total: 92 hours

Ongoing maintenance (monthly average)

• System updates: 2 hours
• Monitoring and alerts: 1 hour
• Backup verification: 1 hour
• Performance optimization: 2 hours
• Total: 6 hours/month

Cost of time

• Setup cost (at $100/hour): $9,200
• Monthly maintenance (at $100/hour): $600
• Annual maintenance cost: $7,200

True annual cost: $8,244 (setup amortized + maintenance + hosting) SaaS equivalent: $36,000 Net savings: $27,756 (77% reduction)

Risk assessment

Self-hosted risks:

• Single VPS failure (mitigated: automated backups, 4-hour recovery)
• Security vulnerabilities (mitigated: automated updates, monitoring)
• Technical knowledge dependency (mitigated: documentation, automation)
• Scaling bottlenecks (acceptable: current capacity handles 10x growth)

SaaS risks:

• Vendor lock-in and data portability issues
• Price increases (common: 20-50% annually)
• Feature deprecation or changes
• Service outages beyond our control
• Data privacy and compliance concerns

Performance Comparison

Website performance

Self-hosted (nginx + CDN):

• Load time: 0.8 seconds globally
• Uptime: 99.97% (measured over 6 months)
• Total requests handled: 250,000+
• Zero bandwidth overage charges

Vercel equivalent:

• Load time: 1.2 seconds (edge network)
• Uptime: 99.99% (published SLA)
• Bandwidth costs: $200+ for our traffic levels

CRM performance

Twenty CRM (self-hosted):

• Response time: <100ms (local network)
• Custom fields: Unlimited
• API rate limits: None
• Data export: Instant, any format

HubSpot Professional:

• Response time: 300-800ms (depends on location)
• Custom fields: 1,000 limit, $5,000 for more
• API rate limits: 100,000/day
• Data export: Limited formats, scheduled

Scaling considerations

Current capacity

Our $80/month VPS handles:

• 50,000 monthly website visitors
• 500 CRM contacts with full activity tracking
• 5,000 email subscribers with campaigns
• 10GB of data storage with automated backups
• Multiple development environments

Scaling path

Vertical scaling (next 2 years):

• Upgrade to 16GB VPS: $160/month
• Capacity: 200,000 monthly visitors, 5,000 CRM contacts

Horizontal scaling (years 3-5):

• Add second VPS: $240/month total
• Load balancer + database separation
• Capacity: 1M+ monthly visitors, 50,000+ CRM contacts

SaaS equivalent scaling:

• HubSpot Enterprise: $5,000+/month
• Vercel bandwidth overages: $1,000+/month
• Mailchimp scaling: $800+/month
• Total: $6,800+/month

The Unexpected Benefits

Technical credibility

Self-hosting gave us immediate credibility with technical clients:

• "You built your own infrastructure? We trust you with ours."
• Deeper understanding of technical challenges businesses face
• Ability to offer infrastructure consulting as an additional service

Business resilience

• No vendor can shut down our business operations
• Complete control over costs and features
• Data portability is never a concern
• Technical skills became a competitive advantage

Customization freedom

Examples of customizations impossible with SaaS:

• CRM integrated directly with website contact forms
• Custom email templates matching brand exactly
• Automated workflows between all systems
• Real-time analytics dashboard combining all data sources

When SaaS Makes Sense

Despite our success with self-hosting, SaaS is better when:

Limited technical resources:

• No one on team comfortable with command line
• Cannot dedicate 6+ hours monthly to maintenance
• Prefer to focus 100% on core business

Compliance requirements:

• HIPAA, SOC 2, or similar certifications required
• Regulatory requirements exceed technical capabilities
• Audit trails and compliance reporting needed

Rapid scaling needs:

• Planning to 10x users within 12 months
• Geographic distribution requirements
• Need enterprise support SLAs

Cash flow positive:

• Monthly recurring revenue > $50,000
• Time is more valuable than money
• Premium support is worth the cost

Decision Framework for Others

Calculate your break-even point

Formula: (SaaS Annual Cost - Self-Hosted Annual Cost) ÷ (Setup Hours × Hourly Rate + Annual Maintenance Hours × Hourly Rate)

Example with our numbers: ($36,000 - $1,044) ÷ (92 × $100 + 72 × $100) = $34,956 ÷ $16,400 = 2.1x ROI

If your result is > 1.5x, self-hosting likely makes financial sense.

Risk tolerance assessment

High risk tolerance (favor self-hosting):

• Comfortable with command line and Linux
• Enjoy learning new technologies
• Have 4+ hours monthly for maintenance
• Value complete control over data and costs

Low risk tolerance (favor SaaS):

• Prefer polished interfaces and support
• Want to focus purely on business development
• Cannot afford any downtime
• Compliance requirements are strict

Our Recommendations by Stage

Pre-revenue startup

• Self-host everything possible
• Use free tiers for essentials (GitHub, etc.)
• Learn as you build
• Document everything for team growth

$1K-$10K MRR

• Hybrid approach
• Self-host core infrastructure
• Use SaaS for specialized tools (payment processing, etc.)
• Invest savings in growth

$10K+ MRR

• Evaluate case-by-case
• Keep self-hosting where you have expertise
• Consider SaaS for new requirements
• Time becomes more valuable than money

Expected outcomes

Financial impact:

• Significant monthly cost reduction vs SaaS alternatives
• Extended runway for bootstrapped startups
• One-time setup investment vs ongoing subscription costs

Technical impact:

• Full control over uptime and performance
• Direct access to security configurations
• No vendor-imposed limitations
• Complete business continuity ownership

Business impact:

• Technical credibility with enterprise-minded clients
• Complete data ownership and privacy
• Zero vendor dependencies
• Skills that translate to client consulting

Conclusion

Self-hosting isn't for everyone, but for technically-minded bootstrapped startups, it can be a game-changer. The potential for significant cost reduction can extend runway and establish technical credibility that differentiates you from competitors.

The key is being honest about your technical capabilities, time availability, and risk tolerance. If you can commit to the learning curve and ongoing maintenance, self-hosting offers unmatched control and cost savings.

Our advice: Start small, document everything, automate relentlessly, and only scale complexity as your business grows.

---

Previous: From Zero to Deployed: Building a Professional Website with Next.js and Tailwind Next: Systems Thinking vs Quick Fixes: Why Most Small Businesses Choose Wrong